All photos (3)One if by Land, Two if by Sea
One if by Land, Two if by Sea
One if by Land, Two if by Sea

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

8.610 reviews
££££
American
Popular with:
  • 9.8
    Luxury Travellers
  • 7.7
    Foodies
Write Review
Bookmark
17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014
(212) 255-8649
http://www.oneifbyland.com/
Edit info
My boyfriend and I came here for a belated Valentine's Day dinner. We chose the Three Course Prix Fixe menu which filled us up perfectly. The grass-fed lamb saddle entree was ... Read more
extremely flavorful and tender. The side of smashed potatoes with truffle was also delicious. The ambiance of One If By Land was perfect; between the pianist, the candlelit table setting with white roses, it all created an incredibly romantic experience.

Member Reviews(10)

Reviews
8.6/10
Wonderful!
5
4
3
2
1
Sort by
Most Helpful
Show Local Reviews
Edinburgh

This place I super romantic and the food is great. I had the beef Wellington which was amazing. The staff could have been more attentive but we had a really positive time.

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

Featured in several movies, this is a restaurant with a beautiful ambience and even more importantly, good food:-) It's also really cool because it's a transformed carriage house (i.e., a garage for carriages from back in the day). It looks nothing like the inside from the outside.

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

One If by Land, Two If by Sea feels like you walked into old time movie set. It is very classic and pretty. A bit pretensions but the service was top notch. The menu and food itself was good but I expected great and it did not deliver. If you have an opportunity to try it - you should do it, but I probably will not be back.

Recommended for:Luxury Travellers
Helpful1
Report
Local from New York City

Take a carriage house, candlelight, grand piano and a live singer and wow! Can you get anymore romantic? Now granted, the tourists have definitely gotten in here enough to sometimes make you cringe but if they dress the part, why not? The food is very good, not fall out of your chair amazing but still worthy of a reservation requirement.

Helpful
Report
Washington, D.C.
First to Review

My boyfriend and I came here for a belated Valentine's Day dinner. We chose the Three Course Prix Fixe menu which filled us up perfectly. The grass-fed lamb saddle entree was extremely flavorful and tender. The side of smashed potatoes with truffle was also delicious. The ambiance of One If By Land was perfect; between the pianist, the candlelit table setting with white roses, it all created an incredibly romantic experience.

Helpful
Report
Syracuse

Beautiful romantic restaurant located in Greenwich Village.

Helpful
Report

Perfect place for the perfect date.

Recommended for:Luxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Hong Kong
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City
Helpful
Report
One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Show Nearby Places

Loading...
40.73257-74.00265
Gansevoort Meatpacking NYC
Gansevoort Meatpacking NYC
8.232 reviews
Distance: 0.53 mi
Soho House New York
Soho House New York
9.123 reviews
Distance: 0.58 mi
The Jane
The Jane
7.515 reviews
Distance: 0.53 mi
The Mercer Hotel
The Mercer Hotel
9.210 reviews
Distance: 0.57 mi
View all
Blue Note Jazz Club
Blue Note Jazz Club
8.816 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Jazz Club, Music Venue
Distance: 0.16 mi
Fat Cat
Fat Cat
8.314 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Bar
Distance: 0.08 mi
Wilfie & Nell
Wilfie & Nell
9.17 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Bar
Distance: 0.11 mi
Marie's Crisis
Marie's Crisis
9.76 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Piano Bar
Distance: 0.06 mi
View all
John's of Bleecker Street
John's of Bleecker Street
9.217 reviews
££££
Italian, Pizza
Distance: 0.07 mi
Buvette
Buvette
9.414 reviews
££££
French, Bar, Cafe
Distance: 0.09 mi
The Little Owl
The Little Owl
8.416 reviews
££££
American, Mediterranean
Distance: 0.14 mi
Keste
Keste
8.313 reviews
££££
Italian, Pizza
Distance: 0.07 mi
View all
Report this place