All photos (7)Don Antonio
Don Antonio
Don Antonio

Don Antonio

9.611 reviews
££££
Italian, Pizza, Wine Bar
Popular with:
  • 9.8
    Foodies
  • 7.4
    Family Travellers
  • 6.3
    Vegetarian
  • 6.2
    Hipsters
Write Review
Bookmark
309 West 50th Street, New York City, NY 10019
(646) 719-1043
https://www.donantoniopizza.com/
Edit info
I had this on my list as a good place for pizza. It's run by the same people that run one of the best/most famous pizza places in Naples (Starita). The Montanara pizza is deep ... Read more
fried (the crust anyway) and very interesting! I don't even usually like smoked cheese, but I liked it on this!

Member Reviews(11)

Reviews
9.6/10
Wonderful!
5
4
3
2
1
Sort by
Most Helpful
Show Local Reviews
Edinburgh

Great food, great service and wonderful selection of Italian beer (i.e. Not Peroni!)

Recommended for:Family TravellersFoodies
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

Tasty pizza's made with amazing pizza dough. Awesome pistachio pesto sauce. Tasty panini's Full bar.

Recommended for:Business TravellersFamily TravellersFoodiesHipsters
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

So I tend to avoid Times Square area but when the parents came in to see a show I searched for good pizza places. This place is AMAZING. Thin crust pies super fresh and many options. They are used to the theater crowd so while there may be a wait they do get you in and out before the show. One pizza is good per person but I recommend trying a few and splitting. I saw locals there too and I would definitely go back even if I didn't have theater tickets

Recommended for:Budget TravellersFamily TravellersFoodiesVegetarian
Helpful
Report
Colorado Springs

I had to grab a quick dinner before a show and these guys nailed it. The pave was packed and I can see why. My pizza, the pizza del rey, was delicious! So worth it!

Recommended for:Budget TravellersFoodiesHistory Buffs
Helpful
Report
Arlington

I had this on my list as a good place for pizza. It's run by the same people that run one of the best/most famous pizza places in Naples (Starita). The Montanara pizza is deep fried (the crust anyway) and very interesting! I don't even usually like smoked cheese, but I liked it on this!

Helpful
Report
Kiryat Gat

One of the best pizzas I ever had. Delicious, well-made, great value for money, lots of menu variety (vegan, gluten free), excellent and friendly service. Definitely will visit again next time I'm in NY.

Recommended for:Vegetarian
Helpful
Report
worldwide
First to Review

Thanks for the great suggestions!! I will try one after the other!
At moment I experimented that pizza and I can tell you is really like my home town Napoli ;)
Don Antonio
www.donantoniopizza.com

Helpful1
Report
Dacula
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City
Helpful
Report
Phoenix
Helpful
Report
Toluca
Helpful
Report
Don Antonio

Show Nearby Places

Loading...
40.762756-73.9867
The Hampton Inn Times Square North
The Hampton Inn Times Square North
8.410 reviews
Distance: 0.06 mi
citizenM New York Times Square
citizenM New York Times Square
8.88 reviews
Distance: 0.13 mi
The Time New York
The Time New York
7.410 reviews
Distance: 0.14 mi
The Belvedere
The Belvedere
7.77 reviews
Distance: 0.09 mi
View all
Wicked New York
Wicked New York
8.935 reviews
Performing Arts, Theatre, Indie or Off Broadway Theatre
Distance: 0.14 mi
Eugene O'Neill Theatre
Eugene O'Neill Theatre
9.010 reviews
Performing Arts, Theatre
Distance: 0.15 mi
Jersey Boys
Jersey Boys
8.76 reviews
Performing Arts, Theatre
Distance: 0.03 mi
CloudM New York Times Square
CloudM New York Times Square
8.02 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Bar, Hotel Bar, Rooftop Bar
Distance: 0.13 mi
View all
Totto Ramen
Totto Ramen
9.333 reviews
££££
Ramen
Distance: 0.12 mi
Ippudo Westside
Ippudo Westside
9.111 reviews
Japanese, Ramen
Distance: 0.04 mi
Toloache
Toloache
8.711 reviews
££££
Mexican, Family Style, Tex-Mex
Distance: 0.07 mi
Island Burgers and Shakes
Island Burgers and Shakes
8.97 reviews
££££
American, Burgers
Distance: 0.13 mi
View all
Report this place