All photos (40)Eataly
Eataly
Eataly

Eataly

199 reviews
££££
Italian, Specialty Food Stores
Popular with:
  • 9.8
    Foodies
  • 6.7
    Hipsters
  • 6.3
    Luxury Travellers
  • 6.1
    Family Travellers
Write Review
Bookmark
200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
(212) 229-2560
http://www.eataly.com/
Edit info
Description
Eataly is more than a supermarket with restaurants. It is an energetic marketplace, an opportunity to taste and take home the products of artisans who till, knead and press to bring you the highest ... Read more
quality products at fair price. We have assembled the absolute best Italian producers from every region under one roof and the absolute best chefs to cook their wares; Eataly is the heartbeat of Italy. We want to challenge the idea that quality products are accessible only to a select few. We’ve done it in Italy: Torino, Bologna, Milano, Pinerolo, Asti and Japan: Tokyo, Daikanyama, Mitsukoshi & Gransta, now it’s time to take New York. Our new New York address does not mean we are only about importing. Our bread is made with New York flour, our gelato is whipped up with local dairy and our meat, produce and fish are almost always American. Grazie, America!

Member Reviews(199)

Reviews
4.6/5
Wonderful!
5
4
3
2
1
Sort by
Most Helpful
Show Local Reviews
Pro 2018
Local from Brooklyn

This place is so great, you can shop to make an Italian feast of fresh pasta and ingredients. You can also grab a bite to eat!!

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

If you're looking for a spread of almost every style of Italian food, Eataly is your place. You can either go shopping to find what you need to cook your own Italian meal or dine in for some amazing food. Their pizza is to die for in this spot and you can take it to walk around the whole space too. Great place for a date or bringing the family.

Recommended for:Family TravellersFoodiesLuxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Hillsboro

Super cute shop! Good coffee and amazing food! They have so much to offer here! It’s almost like a little Italian mini-mart!

Recommended for:Budget TravellersFoodiesHipstersArt & Design Lovers
Helpful
Report
Seoul

I was really expected to go to Eataly, but This place was too crowded and narrow. People was too many so I couldn’t have a meal inside.

Recommended for:Family TravellersFoodiesStudents
Helpful
Report
Puerto Vallarta

Oh my goodness! Amazing! Like a traditional Mediterranean market "done up" in a BIG New York City way! A vast space with just about anything you could want, so massive they have several restaurants inside the shop from which to choose!

I was in the city and looking for somewhere to go for dinner. I checked my Trip.com iPhone app and saw the reviews for Eataly and had to check it out!

Thanks so many Trip.com users for such an amazing experience!

Recommended for:FoodiesHipsters
Helpful1
Report
Local from New York City

OMG! Italian food lovers this is the place to go in New York City. The food is incredible, pasta is fresh, many great choices. Place is charming.

Recommended for:FoodiesHipstersSolo Female
Helpful
Report
Cortlandt

What a great place!! First time is the charm!! Foodie heaven! The variety of food is incredible!!

Recommended for:Family TravellersFoodiesLuxury Travellers
Helpful
Report
Pro 2018
Covina

Cool place for italian, lots of restaurants and italian market shops to get pasta!

Helpful1
Report
Leesburg

How do you choose between the numerous types of olive oil and vinegars. Incredible produce, meat, cheese selection and fantastic food options to eat in. Must try the cotton candy grapes when in season!

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury TravellersHipstersSolo Female
Helpful
Report
Barcelona

This is a very interesting concept store/restaurant. Some kind of a mini-mall of all things Italian. I think they have 2-3 different restaurants and few other shops. I had a great experience overall and totally recommend it.

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury TravellersHipsters
Helpful
Report
Local from Brooklyn

Eatly has the most delicious Tiramisu and cakes, these are the Valentine's Day version:)

Recommended for:Foodies
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

Not cheap but perfect for teenager dinner at the pasta pizza spot. Love the seafood and veg spots for when the kids are not with us.

Recommended for:FoodiesVegetarianArt & Design Lovers
Helpful
Report
Palo Alto

Eataly is huge market with a diverse selection of Italian products, shops and restaurants!

Recommended for:Family TravellersFoodies
Helpful
Report
San Diego

Anything you wish to imagine as far as Italian food , market experience .. Love it

Recommended for:Business TravellersFamily TravellersFoodies
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

I love this tourist trap! I enjoy a bolangese panini and although I had to wait particularly long (approx 20 mins) it was well worth it!

Helpful
Report
Waterford

Such a fun place. Has so many different types of foods beers and wine. They have sit down eating as well which I didn't do but smelled amazing!

Recommended for:Foodies
Helpful
Report
Local from New York City

The Mecca for all things gourmet Italian, you can't go wrong when you stop by this gorgeous market. Anything from the high tops where you can order fresh cheese and wine, the specialty restaurants like the pasta and seafood ones, you'll enjoy everything you eat here! Fair warning: it is super packed on the weekends and can get pricey very easily.

Recommended for:FoodiesLuxury TravellersHipsters
Helpful
Report
Local from Brooklyn

Are you a foodie? If so, you must come here and sample the different shops. I personally love the panini section; they have such delicious and great quality cuts of meats and cheeses they put in their sandwiches which truly makes the difference. Still have plenty more sections to try out within Eataly and I can't wait to try it all.

Recommended for:FoodiesHipsters
Helpful
Report
Pro 2018
Huntington Beach

I loved the food here and my rating is based on mom that. The experience tho chaotic was a foodie lovers dreams and beyond delicious!!

Recommended for:FoodiesHipsters
Helpful
Report
Philadelphia

This place is HUGE. It gets really crowded and the items on sale are pricey. But the gelato is good, and though I have yet to get a meal from any of the restaurants, I'm sure they are just as good.

Recommended for:FoodiesWellnessLuxury Travellers
Helpful1
Report
Eataly

Show Nearby Places

Loading...
40.742188-73.98989
Flatiron Hotel
Flatiron Hotel
7 reviews
Distance: 0.13 mi
Comfort Inn Chelsea
Comfort Inn Chelsea
2 reviews
Distance: 0.1 mi
Ace Hotel New York
Ace Hotel New York
57 reviews
Distance: 0.26 mi
The NoMad Hotel
The NoMad Hotel
14 reviews
Distance: 0.2 mi
View all
Flatiron Building
Flatiron Building
123 reviews
Sights and Museums, Landmark, Popular
Distance: 0.08 mi
Madison Square Park
Madison Square Park
76 reviews
Outdoors, Park
Distance: 0.12 mi
Central Park South
Central Park South
32 reviews
Outdoors, Park, Neighbourhood
Distance: 0.04 mi
Birreria
Birreria
9 reviews
Bars, Clubs and Nightlife, Brewery
Distance: 0.03 mi
View all
Shake Shack
Shake Shack
178 reviews
££££
Fast Food, Burgers
Distance: 0.13 mi
Hill Country Chicken
Hill Country Chicken
10 reviews
££££
American, Southern / Soul
Distance: 0.08 mi
Madison Square Eats
Madison Square Eats
7 reviews
££££
American, Street Food & Stands
Distance: 0.04 mi
SERRA by Birreria
SERRA by Birreria
6 reviews
££££
Italian
Distance: 0.02 mi
View all

Aliases: Eatly, Eataly Downtown

Report this place